“A Dominion in Uniform: Canada’s Military Awakening, 1867–1914”
At its birth in 1867, Canada was not forged by revolution nor scorched by civil war, but assembled—deliberately and diplomatically—like a well-joined table. Yet the young Dominion, cradled in British imperial arms, found itself in a world still ruled by the bayonet. The rifles had fallen silent at Gettysburg, but sabres rattled anew across Europe and the Pacific. And if the new country wished to survive with dignity, it had to reckon with the old truths: that peace is sustained not just by treaty but by strength.
The Canadian military at Confederation was more notional than national. “The militia,” quipped one British officer, “was better suited for parades than campaigns.” Canada had no standing army to speak of—only scattered rifle associations, a few dusty forts, and the legacy of frontier skirmishes. The British garrisons, still stationed in Halifax and Quebec, represented the backbone of defense, but by the 1870s, even those redcoats would march home. Canada would have to stand on its own legs—or stumble.
In Ottawa, the challenge was philosophical as much as logistical. What was a Canadian soldier? The British North America Act provided a structure of governance, but not of identity. “A Canadian army, distinct and yet loyal,” mused George-Étienne Cartier, “might prove the litmus of our national manhood.” Still, budgets were scarce, interest was thin, and most farmers viewed militarism with a colonial wariness. Defense was, at best, a footnote.
That began to change with the Fenian Raids of the 1860s and 70s—Irish-American veterans storming across the border in nationalist fervor. Though absurd in scope, these incursions struck a nerve. A militia act was passed in 1868. Fortifications were strengthened. The threat had been small, but the psychological effect was large: the idea of Canadian soil, defended by Canadian hands, began to take root.
Through the 1880s and 90s, the Dominion continued to professionalize. Schools of military instruction were established, and the first permanent units—like the Royal Canadian Regiment—were slowly mustered. Yet Canada remained a country that prepared for war with a librarian’s discretion: diligently, but quietly.
Then, in 1885, came blood on the prairie. The Northwest Rebellion, led by Louis Riel and Métis resistance, tested the fledgling state’s capacity for internal war. The Canadian militia mobilized rapidly, riding the new transcontinental railway to Batoche. It was not merely a campaign of rifles and strategy—it was a crucible of loyalty and control. For some, it was the birth of the modern Canadian army. For others, it was a tragedy of misunderstanding and repression.
By the turn of the 20th century, Canada began to eye the world stage—not out of ambition, but from imperial obligation. The Boer War (1899–1902) became the Dominion’s first real foreign conflict. Nearly 7,000 Canadians volunteered to fight in South Africa. “It was a coming-of-age ritual in khaki,” writes historian Desmond Morton, “and a rehearsal for far greater trials to come.” The Canadian troops performed admirably, and Victoria Crosses were won. But the war also exposed tension at home: French Canadians, led by Henri Bourassa, decried the campaign as Britain’s folly—not Canada’s cause.
As the Empire flexed abroad, Canada built at home. The Naval Service Act of 1910, championed by Prime Minister Wilfrid Laurier, attempted to establish a Canadian navy. But it split the nation. English Canadians wanted more ships for Britain; French Canadians wanted none at all. “We are either a country or we are not,” lamented Laurier. “If we are, let us act like one.” The fledgling Royal Canadian Navy was born—small, underfunded, and politically volatile.
By 1914, Canada’s military was still modest, but no longer imaginary. A tiny regular force of 3,000 men was supported by a militia of over 60,000—many untrained. It was a system built more on enthusiasm than efficiency. Still, beneath the patchy structure lay something new: a flicker of national identity tied to uniform, to duty, to sacrifice.
When Britain declared war on Germany in August of 1914, Canada followed automatically—but not unthinkingly. The response was electric. Over 30,000 men enlisted in the first weeks. They were not yet “the storm troopers of Vimy” nor “the ghosts of Passchendaele,” but they were Canadians—in arms, on ships, marching to the thunder of Europe.
This was not a nation eager for empire. It was a nation asserting itself—hesitantly, perhaps, but unmistakably. As one volunteer wrote home, “We are not British soldiers. We are Canadian soldiers… and we go in our own name.”
References
- Cook, T. (2006). Clio’s Warriors: Canadian Historians and the Writing of the World Wars. UBC Press.
- Douglas, W. A. B. (1992). Marching to Different Drums: Canadian Military History. Journal of Military History. Link
- Martin, G. (1995). Britain and the Origins of Canadian Confederation, 1837–67. University of Toronto Press.
- Morton, D. (1987). Defending the Indefensible: Canadian Defence, 1867–1987. International Journal, 42(4). DOI
- Nicholson, G. W. L. (2015). Canadian Expeditionary Force, 1914–1919: Official History. McGill-Queen’s University Press.
- Sharpe, C. (2015). Enlistment in the Canadian Expeditionary Force. Canadian Military History, 24(1). PDF
- Bothwell, R., & Colbourn, S. (2014). Canada and the British Commonwealth in the Great War. Histoire@Politique. PDF
- Borys, D. (2024). Punching Above Our Weight: The Canadian Military at War Since 1867.
- Milner, M. (1989). Reflections on Canadian Army History in the Two World Wars. Acadiensis. PDF
- Creighton, D. (1958). The United States and Canadian Confederation. Canadian Historical Review. Link