WW I – Post War – The Cost

Canada’s involvement in the First World War marked a transformative period for the nation, both in terms of the profound human cost and the reshaping of its military and international identity. By the time the Armistice was signed on November 11, 1918, Canada had emerged as a respected fighting force with significant battlefield accomplishments, yet these achievements came at an immense cost. The post-war period witnessed Canada’s growing independence from British influence, which was formally acknowledged when the nation played a role in the Versailles Peace Treaty negotiations. Historian G.W.L. Nicholson described Canada’s journey through and beyond the Great War as one that “transformed a colonial dominion into a nation of international standing, its identity forged in the crucible of global conflict” (Canadian Expeditionary Force: 1914–1919).

The Human Cost: Casualties and Losses for Canada

The human cost of the First World War was staggering for Canada. Over 619,000 Canadians enlisted in the armed forces, a significant number given Canada’s population of just over eight million at the time. Of these, approximately 61,000 were killed in combat or from wounds and disease, and another 172,000 were wounded. These losses represented nearly 10% of all Canadians who served. Many of the men who survived returned home with lifelong injuries, both physical and psychological, a generation marked by what came to be known as “shell shock” or post-traumatic stress disorder.

In battles like Ypres, the Somme, Vimy Ridge, and Passchendaele, Canadian soldiers faced relentless artillery, machine-gun fire, and the horrors of trench warfare. At Vimy Ridge, one of Canada’s most celebrated victories, the Canadian Corps achieved an impressive tactical success, but not without suffering over 10,000 casualties. Historian Tim Cook wrote, “The achievements of the Canadian Corps were paid for in blood, each advance marked by the loss of a generation that would never return” (Shock Troops). The human toll of these battles was felt deeply across Canada, where nearly every community had lost men to the war.

The losses extended beyond the battlefield. The families of fallen soldiers, many of whom were the primary breadwinners, faced significant hardships. The government established the Board of Pension Commissioners to provide support, but this could never fully address the economic and emotional devastation wrought by the loss of so many young men. These losses also fostered a sense of pride and respect for the sacrifices made, leading to the establishment of war memorials across the country as Canadians sought to honor those who had given their lives.

The Economic Cost and Post-War Challenges

The war placed an enormous financial burden on Canada, fundamentally altering the nation’s economy. By 1918, Canada’s national debt had soared from $463 million to $2.46 billion, primarily due to the costs of maintaining and supplying the Canadian Expeditionary Force. To cover these expenses, the government introduced new taxes, including the Income War Tax Act of 1917, a temporary measure that eventually became a permanent fixture of Canadian taxation.

In addition to these fiscal burdens, the post-war period brought challenges in reintegrating veterans into civilian life. Many returning soldiers found that jobs were scarce, and the government struggled to meet its commitments for veterans’ benefits. Social tensions also arose, as war veterans were often frustrated with the slow pace of support and the difficulties of readjusting to civilian society. Historian Desmond Morton observed, “The war left deep scars on Canadian society, scars that were not only physical but economic and psychological, shaping a generation’s view of government and duty” (When Your Number’s Up).

The Impact on Canada’s Military and Strategic Orientation

The experience of the First World War transformed the Canadian military into a respected fighting force with a newfound sense of professionalism and independence. Prior to the war, Canada’s military had been small and largely subordinate to British command. However, by the war’s end, the Canadian Corps had achieved a series of impressive victories and had operated under the command of Canadian officers, most notably Lieutenant-General Sir Arthur Currie, who commanded the Canadian Corps from 1917 onward. Currie’s leadership at battles like Vimy Ridge, Passchendaele, and the Hundred Days Offensive solidified his reputation and the Canadian Corps’ status as elite troops. Historian C.P. Stacey noted, “The Canadian Corps, under Currie’s leadership, had become one of the most effective fighting formations on the Western Front, a force respected by allies and feared by enemies” (Canada and the Age of Conflict).

The successes of the Canadian Corps fostered a sense of national pride and a demand for greater autonomy in military affairs. The Canadian government sought to ensure that Canadian soldiers served under Canadian command, rather than being simply absorbed into British forces. This shift toward independence laid the groundwork for the future development of the Royal Canadian Air Force (established in 1924) and a distinct Canadian Army. The war had demonstrated Canada’s ability to organize, train, and lead its own forces, and this newfound confidence would influence Canadian defense policy in the years to come.

Despite this evolution, Canada faced challenges in maintaining a large standing army during peacetime. The immediate post-war period saw a significant reduction in Canada’s military, as the nation reverted to a smaller, more cost-effective force. The “war to end all wars” left many Canadians with a deep-seated aversion to future military engagements, a sentiment that would influence Canada’s cautious approach to international conflicts for decades.

Canada’s Role in the Versailles Peace Treaty

Canada’s contributions to the war effort and its significant sacrifices earned the nation a place at the Versailles Peace Conference in 1919. This marked a watershed moment for Canada, as it was the first time the country participated in an international treaty negotiation as a separate entity, rather than as a colonial extension of Britain. Prime Minister Robert Borden argued forcefully for Canada’s inclusion, asserting that Canada’s sacrifices on the battlefield warranted a voice in shaping the post-war world. Historian G.W.L. Nicholson wrote, “Canada’s presence at Versailles symbolized a new chapter in its international status, a step toward independence that had been hard-won on the fields of France” (Canadian Expeditionary Force: 1914–1919).

Borden’s efforts were successful, and Canada was granted two seats at the conference, alongside the other Dominions of the British Empire. Although Canada’s influence at Versailles was limited, its presence marked a turning point. Canada signed the Treaty of Versailles independently, a symbolic act that underscored its emerging autonomy within the British Empire. The treaty formally recognized Canada as a distinct entity in international law, and Canada subsequently joined the League of Nations as an independent member.

While Canada’s role at Versailles was primarily symbolic, its presence underscored a broader shift in its relationship with Britain. The experience of the war and Canada’s participation in the peace process fostered a sense of nationalism and a desire for greater independence. Historian J.L. Granatstein remarked, “The Versailles Treaty was more than a diplomatic agreement for Canada; it was a declaration of intent, a signal that Canada would pursue its own path in the world” (Canada’s Army).

The Legacy of World War I for Canada

The First World War left an indelible mark on Canada, reshaping its military, political, and social landscape. The war transformed Canada’s relationship with Britain, catalyzing the nation’s journey toward independence. The sacrifices made by Canadian soldiers fostered a sense of national pride and unity, even as the losses brought lasting grief to communities across the country. Memorials were erected, and Remembrance Day was established as a solemn occasion to honor those who had served and sacrificed.

The war also had a profound impact on Canada’s military development. The success of the Canadian Corps on the battlefield and the command experience gained by officers like Currie laid the foundation for a more autonomous and professional Canadian military. The lessons learned during the war would shape Canadian defense policy and the organization of the armed forces in the decades to follow.

In the words of historian Desmond Morton, “The First World War was Canada’s baptism of fire, a trial that transformed it from a colony into a nation, with a place among the world’s great powers” (A Military History of Canada). The legacy of the war endured in the hearts and minds of Canadians, a reminder of the sacrifices made and the nation’s emergence onto the global stage.

Conclusion: The Price of War and the Path Forward

The First World War exacted a heavy toll on Canada, both in terms of lives lost and the financial and emotional burdens it imposed. Yet, from this crucible of conflict, Canada emerged as a more united and independent nation. The war fostered a sense of national identity and pride, a belief in Canada’s ability to stand on its own. The experience of the Canadian Corps on the battlefields of Europe and Canada’s role in the Versailles Treaty reflected a newfound confidence, a desire to shape its own destiny.

The legacy of the First World War is a complex one, woven from threads of sacrifice, loss, and resilience. Canada’s place at Versailles was a symbolic recognition of the price it had paid and the contributions it had made. For Canada, the First World War was a transformative experience, a chapter that would shape its future, its military, and its place in the world.


References

  1. Nicholson, G.W.L. Canadian Expeditionary Force: 1914–1919. Queen’s Printer, 1962.
  2. Morton, Desmond. When Your Number’s Up: The Canadian Soldier in the First World War. Random House Canada, 1993.
  3. Stacey, C.P. Canada and the Age of Conflict: A History of Canadian External Policies. University of Toronto Press, 1984.
  4. Cook, Tim. Shock Troops: Canadians Fighting the Great War, 1917–1918. Viking Canada, 2008.
  5. Granatstein, J.L. Canada’s Army: Waging War and Keeping the Peace. University of Toronto Press, 2002.